The £500 note: how a messy WhatsApp history can lose you a deposit dispute

In a deposit dispute, the burden of proof is on the landlord. What a maintenance log needs to show, and why a chat thread on your phone falls short.

By Calum Hopkins, founder of Lettie · · Updated · 3 min read

In short

  • In a deposit dispute, the deposit stays the tenant's money until you prove your claim.
  • A chat thread on your own phone isn't a maintenance log. Adjudicators want clear, time-stamped evidence of when an issue was reported and what you did.
  • Lettie logs each tenant report on WhatsApp as a time-stamped record against the property. You add your own notes, and can export the record as a PDF.

It's one of the worst parts of being a landlord: a deposit dispute. You've kept back £500 for damage, and your tenant disputes it through the deposit protection scheme. In England that's one of three: the Deposit Protection Service, mydeposits or the Tenancy Deposit Scheme.

The tenant claims, "The damage was caused by a leak I reported in March, but the landlord never fixed it." You know they only told you in July, but your only proof is a WhatsApp thread on your own phone from six months ago, mixed in with everything else. Who will the adjudicator believe?

The one with dates, because you have to prove your claim.

What a maintenance log has to show

Keep the report, messages, photos and actions together, with their dates. Here's what the log needs to show an adjudicator:

Everything in one place
A dedicated system, like a dashboard or a spreadsheet, shows every issue on every property.
Clear times
It shows when an issue was reported, when you responded and when it was resolved, so you can answer a "you were too slow" claim with dates.
What you did
It shows the steps you took. "Spoke to tenant 10/05, AI triaged issue 10/05, Plumber contacted 11/05, Job completed 13/05."
What it cost
With quotes and invoices kept against each repair, you can show the adjudicator what the work cost.

Why a chat on your phone falls short

Texts get deleted, phones get replaced, and one thread mixes the leak with the bin day. The adjudicator is left piecing dates together from screenshots.

How Lettie keeps the log for you

When a tenant reports a problem to Lettie on WhatsApp, Lettie opens a report against the property straight away.

  • Every message and photo keeps its time.
  • Lettie's summary and urgency rating are saved on the report.
  • You mark it resolved when the job's done, or close it with a reason.
  • You can add your own private notes ("Called ABC Plumbers, quote £150").

When the tenancy ends, export the report as a PDF for the adjudicator, with the original photos and files in a ZIP.

Back to that leak. Had the tenant reported it to Lettie, the report would show their first message arrived in July, with its time, and the PDF would put that date in front of the adjudicator.

See the repair record.

  • Awaab's Law: who it applies to and the deadlines

    Social landlords in England must make emergencies safe in 24 hours and investigate damp and mould in 10 working days. Private landlords aren't covered yet.

    Repair law and certificatesFor social landlords, private landlords and letting agents
    6 min read · Checked 10 November 2026
    See who it covers and the deadlines
  • Tenant-like manner: what Warren v Keen means for landlords

    What "tenant-like manner" means after Warren v Keen: the small jobs a tenant is expected to handle, and how to keep a record of who did what.

    Landlord law14 November 2025 · Updated 10 November 2026 · 3 min readRead the post

Get a price,
or start free

Agency plans are priced on your properties and team seats. For landlords, Lettie is free for up to 4 properties.